Hi Michael ! Just had to chime in on this one. We got Bogey at 8 weeks old. Breeder had him on Eukanuba, which I immediately changed ( well slowly transitioned) to Fromms puppy. Formed stool first thing in am, loosening as the day wore on, and going 8-9 times a day! After MONTHS of trying different foods, all grain free, all with slow transitions, I would end up with the same scenario- formed first thing in the morning, soft serve by mid day, diarrhea by dinner. I tried Pure Vita, NVI, Earthborne and Fromms. This went on up til he was 11 months old! Then, my vet stepped in and put him on Hills Science Diet WD( for glucose and weight management) this happened when I was away and boarded him at the vets. When I got back and saw what she put him on, I went ballistic! OMG! Corn as the first ingredient! chicken! Really low protein and MEGA fiber(. 13 grams!!) I was like, " no way!" But, she asked me to work with her and give this a chance. She said millions of dogs, including bulldogs, do just fine on these diets. Well, gave it a week, and I have NEVER seen such solid poop in my life! I was not convinced though, so I challenged it without her knowing, and slowly transitioned him to yet another " good" dog food, and after 3 days, with only 1/4 cup of the new stuff mixed with his " junk dog food", the soft serve poop stared up again! So, I stopped it, put him back on the Hills, and he has not had ONE soft serve poop since! So, these good dog foods are not for all bullies, and you need to find what works for yours. I hope this helps. Her theory, by the way, was that Bogey has a very irritable bowel, and all the rich ingredients were just irritating him. The high fiber content in this food helps with the water balance, and there isn't a lot of " extras" in it! I DO give him a packet of Purina Fortflora ( probiotics) every am. He has not had any bacterial infection since I put him on this. I tried the human probiotics, but I noticed no difference. My vet told me to try the Purina brand because they are specifically made for dogs, and I noticed a difference right away. Good luck!!