We have the same problem as Todd. Bought a squeaky toy yesterday. $10.00 and I told Weesie I can put a treat inside this and they will play with this for hours. It lasted 1 hour. The only thing that has lasted was the Kong's and they hate them.
No toys last here. Trigger destroyed the many so called "indestructible" ones. We now just get him the whole antlers as his toys. Winston doesn't know what toys are so he gets antlers too. I tried way too many toys too haha.
Yes, we had a giant toy box Little by little the bullies destroyed the "stuffies" so no more-now we are down to less than this! No more stuff-only nylabones and jolly balls.
We have a toy box that we let Ruckus pick from and a stash of brand new toys that we dole out periodically. I stock up at Marshall's and hide them. We also have a rope toy he plays with outside.
Everytime I go shopping I bring home a little something for her. I need to have some place to put it all so we are not tripping on them. Yesterday was her birthday and she got a few more stuffies. I was just thinking with Christmas comining I need another box or to slow down on how much I buy her. Plus it's great that she knows exactly where to go get her toys when she wants to play. Now I just need to teach her to put the toys back when she is done playing.