@ModernFemme I like Plato "thinkers" treat sticks. They come in. 4 flavors , duchess prefers the salmon. they are all natural and last forever because you can cut them to whatever size you want. What I learned in training class is many people use to much treat to train. U really only want to give them the scent and a little nibble the size of a piece of kibble. Also hot dogs are good too, I use turkey or beef all natural from like whole foods or trader joes, relatively inexpensive and they go crazy for them, again can be cut into. Very small pieces.