Hi Shiny...I hope mr.Rondo tail is better...I just wanted to let you know that I had the same problem with our little one Ivy- tail raw skin and bad odor. What I found to work best is to clean it around and deep inside (use qtip or little finger) to get as close to the tail base as possible. I use baby wipes and add few drops of Which Hazel, then I apply generously Destine. It works like magic and she's happy puppy and we are tooooo. Hope this helps you and please don't go for surgeries. Unless it is very very necessary. And always ask for 2nd or 3rd opinion from Specialized Vet. Bulldogs are very very different than any other breads-and can get very complicated if inexperienced vet are looking after your little one! Best regards, Cami and Ivy🐶