American Idol Anyone?

[cali~jenn]

Oh no I hope this doesnt take him out of the competition! He has a real shot at winning! I find it funny how all of us are liking the same 3 to go all the way, guess that tells you pretty much how the show will go unless somebody messes up big time.

[kazzy220]

BUMP

We DVR's this weeks editions so only saw them Friday night.

I now think that Paul is back in the running ... i thought he was so good this week. Casey seems to be losing his edge a bit - I can see why he got voted into the bottom place this week. I know he has his own style, but I think he needs to be just a touch more main stream for the moment until he really gets a fan base, and then start to be alittle more adventurous. Glad he was saved though!!!

[cali~jenn]

I liked Paul at first but he bugs me now I think There is only 1 Rod Stewert so it drives me nuts that he always sounds like that. Sad cuz I know it is just his voice and all. lol. I was shocked to see Casey almost go home, there are so many others that need to go before he gets put back in that spot. This week will be interesting tho with 2 going home!

[JAKEISGREAT]

This is actually the first year we are watching the whole thong and we love the new judges. Thought same thong about not being the same..love it this year..Casey is our fave..ha ha..felt exactly same way about Paul..have to get off and vacuum..so much dog hair..it's all over my iPad..nasty!

[bullmama]

I was so relieved he was saved, I think he is trying too hard to be original.... he has a wonderful voice and we just have not heard it in two weeks. Paul is back and he just has to make sure he can match the song with his voice, Casey is probably my favorite but have been disapointed the past two weeks......

but I must admit I usually don't like girl singers but last week Niema kicked some serious toushie!!! Best performance of the night!

[Luvin My Bullie]

I love Paul and Pia. I also like lauren and stefano

[cali~jenn]

Neima bugs me but she did do the best I have seen her so far. Usually I think she is awful tho, but the judges always like her. I LOVE Pia but she shouldnt even be there, she is that good. My fav is James I think his name is? (tourettes) LOVE him!

[bullmama]

Wow pia was voted off. She was not my fav but still shocked. I must admit that the judges reaction would kinda make the other contestants feel badly.....

[JAKEISGREAT]

I was really surprised about Pia too. She wasn't one of my faves but not because of her talent..she is really a good singer..but her personality just bugged. I thought the judges looked pissed even before the announcement. Especially Jennifer. I think they are told who bottom 3 are ahead of time. This is a year with a lot of talent. Going to be interesting!

[gmaboman]

I think this years talent is great, Pia was a very good singer but her personality was dull, that's why her votes weren't there. She will be ok, she is touring with them and she will get a deal with her looks,

[kazzy220]

Well I have both shows from this week on DVR because it has been so crazy this week .... I guess I don't need to guess who got voted off .....

I'm still going to watch both shows, but I agree with the vote. I know Pia has a wonderful voice but she was really snooze-ville to watch!!

[bullmama]

Oooooops!!! I guess I should've said spoiler alert on my post!!!!