Hi Stacey, I agree with the others, it's best to change from Beneful. My vet always recommends to not buy your dog food from a grocery store or a big box store like Walmart. You are best to choose a food that is rated at a 4 Star or better, which you can find the ratings on the dog food rating under the Nutrition forum on the Home page on this site. It's best to feed EB's chicken, and grain free brands, as many bullies are allergic or sensitive to these ingredients, but every bully is different in what they can tolerate. There are many good brands to choose from.