Mabel pooped a lot but it also was the food I was feeding her as well. Just because it may be a high quality food does not mean it is a poop controller. Seemed like I could fill a poop can very quickly and she was having a good size poop when she went a gazillion times a day lol. I have her on a LID after many different types of food and she goes now morning, afternoon and evening. All being formed so my can doesn't get filled up so quickly now. She is 8mths old now. I think it is just a matter of how their digestive system accepts the food, not every dogs system is going to accept it just because it is a great food that may be rated with a high number to. Also when your baby goes poop you said they are all formed but how much poop is he actually producing each time?