Philly has been a part of our family for more than 2 months now his former owner also feed him scraps, rescue fed him nutro, I tried feeding him Fromm! Very finicky! I had some success with toppers I used Fromm canned, cottage cheese and now since he was given pres. Gastro food he loves turkey! I'm mixing canned turkey potato by blue wild basics grainfree to salmon tunalini. I may change Fromm to bw. He won't eat kibbles with out toppers even if its just grated cheese!