I think totw is a better food. In fact I fed canidae a long time ago and switched from that in my process of finding better foods and moved up to totw. I have since switched a few times but if my choice it would be totw. Have you tried diff flavors? I cant help so much cuz my boys have never not liked any food. Fromm is more expensive but in my experience it must taste great. I joke that they sprinkle crack in there cuz it is the first food I ever had to regulate my boys on. They were free fed before this food and now they over eat this stuff, they love it so much. I know it is hard to find but petflow has free shipping if you use the code englishbulldog and spend 59 I think it is. I always buy a bag of that and a bag of treats to get the free shipping. Even without I think shipping is like 4.99 so very wroth it either way. Just a thought.