Here is a good article that rates dog foods. We feed our pups FROMM Puppy Gold in the pink bag until they are about 7 months old. We did feed our Adults FROMM 4 star but now feed Natural Balance Limited Ingredients Potato and Duck formula. They also can have plain yogurt, some fruits, as in blueberries, strawberries, apple, banana, but no grapes or raisins. They also love peanut butter. For a summer time treat we will mix plain yogurt and peanut butter together and then make bite size drops and freeze them on a cookie sheet, and they love them.